Candide: Adult Discussion Group

Candide book cover

Candide will occupy the members of our Contemporary Issues “Adult Ed.” reading group when they meet Saturday, December 4 at the Elk Grove Panera on Biesterfield Road at 9:30 a.m.

Everyone is welcome, whether you have participated previously or even if you have not yet read the book.

Some members may find Voltaire’s writing a bit challenging, especially his references to places, people, and issues that are now largely forgotten.

I have two hints:

1. Don’t worry about following all the details, and if you feel that the story is getting bogged down and repetitious here and there, you’re probably not alone. It is important that you try to get to the last two or three chapters, even if it means skipping afew in the middle.

2. Think about the problem of evil: Why, if God is good, is there so much evil in the world? Can you explain it? Can anyone in the story?

I have created a “cheatsheet” of textual notes and references; see my Adult Education Program page at http://www.swhi.net/
~steveg/StNick/

and scroll down to the link for “Notes for reading Candide.” It may help.

Where we’ve been, where we’re going

The book club has been going for ten months now, and I thought it might be of interest to recap where we’ve been. Here’s the history so far:

  • January: Nineteen Eighty-Four (George Orwell)
  • February: My Stroke of Insight (Jill Bolte Taylor, Ph.D)
  • March: Mark Twain trio:
    Letters From the Earth
    Extracts from Adam’s Diary
    Eve’s Diary

  • April: Ninety-Five Theses (Martin Luther)
  • May: The Plague (Albert Camus)
  • June: The Immortal Life of Henrietta Lacks (Rebecca Skloot)
  • July: Good Omens (Neil Gaiman and Terry Pratchett)
  • August: Man’s Search for Meaning (Viktor Frankl) and
    Existentialism and Human Emotions (Jean-Paul Sartre)

  • September: The Shack (William P. Young)
  • October: Only a Theory (Kenneth Miller, Ph.D.)

And next:

  • November: Candide (Voltaire)

I’m pretty pleased with the variety and richness of the material we’ve covered. My only regret is that we have not found more people who are both interested and willing to come out on a Saturday morning.

As regular members know, I maintain a page of reference material at http://www.swhi.net/~steveg/StNick/, including a “Suggested Reading List.” I hope it is understood that this is not simply a list of books we have read or may all read together as a group in coming months; some of them, at least, will appeal to a few members but not others, and some (I hope) to members of the St. Nicholas community who are not joining our Saturday morning group at all. All of them are (I believe) potentially of interest anyway. Additions to the list are always welcome.

Also on the main page, I have posted some extra reference materials as to some of the topics we’ve covered. Check back now and then for items related to books we have read or are going to read.

– Steve G

Catching up . . .

SteveG Somehow it’s been a while since I’ve brought this page up to date on what the Book Club has been doing. In July, we read and discussed one of my favorite books, Good Omens: The Nice and Accurate Prophecies of Agnes Nutter, Witch. It wasn’t everyone’s cup of tea, but made for some good discussion about dealing with God’s “ineffable” plan when one thing we know about it is that if there is a plan, it’s beyond our understanding.

Following this, in August we returned to nonfiction with two conceptually related books: Man’s Search for Meaning, by Viktor Frankl, and Existentialism and Human Emotions, a collection of separate essays by Jean-Paul Sartre. Although written from distinctly different perspectives, both books deal with the human need to find meaning in life. Sartre insisted that meaning must be found by each person independently, specifically (in significant part) because he did not believe in God as a source of meaning; Frankl, on the other hand, stressed that regardless of whether a meaning in life is found in religion or elsewhere, it is the deepest need of each human psyche. His doctrine of psychological treatment based on this concept, known as logotherapy, was formed in part before, but tested and further developed during, Frankl’s imprisonment in Auschwitz and other Nazi death camps.

Our September book was our first recent best-seller, The Shack, by William P. Young. Reviews of the book were mixed, but it sparked an interesting discussion of concepts of divinity and the relation of God to Man.

In October we will be tackling the evolution – creationism – “intelligent design” debate, with Only a Theory, by Kevin R. Miller. This educational but highly readable book examines the debate between evolution science and so-called “creation science,” seeking to help people understand what the argument is really about and, more important, why it matters. It does so by examining what each of the major perspectives actually says is true, and what one says (or doesn’t say) about the other. Along the way it provides some education in a careful selection of intriguing science topics, told from a highly expert point of view but clearly explained for non-scientists. We will be meeting to discuss “Only a Theory” on Saturday, October 30, at 9:30 AM. All are welcome!

– Steve G