Why Change Faiths, Or Lose It Entirely?

Has your faith changed? Do you even have it anymore? Do you still feel some attraction toward spirituality, but don’t believe what you thought you believed when you were younger? Changes in faith can be difficult to talk about, but they’re clearly not uncommon.

People change, and they often have questions whose answers change as they grow through life from beginning to middle to end. Some people lose any belief in God they may have had, and in our pluralistic society, this is not to be condemned; but those of us who are believers should question why some people feel they’ve been hurt or not served well by “the institutional church.”

As we heard in Father Manny’s sermon today, if we are invited to a banquet, we should sit at the lowest place so that we might be invited by the host to a place of greater honor.. and if we give a banquet, we should offer it to the poor, the friendless, the sick, the crippled, and “the least of these” in society. We’re called to invite all, welcome all, honor all… and not be downcast if the invitation is not accepted and the welcome refused, or the honor rejected.

We simply continue to invite, welcome, honor… and offer community and fellowship to all.

The recent story of author Anne Rice’s public journey away from organized religion while remaining a believer in Christ and His ministry to the poor, the sick, and the friendless has been all over the Internet – but Barna Research shows that Anne Rice is one among many Americans who on a similar spiritual path.

The Barna Group – Do Americans Change Faiths?

When author Anne Rice recently “quit Christianity” on her Facebook page, she lit up the blogosphere and sparked interest among media. Though the novelist announced that this time she was quitting “in the name of Christ,” her previous journey away from – and back to – the Christian faith had been well chronicled.

Just how common is this type of experience for Americans? How many Americans change faiths? A multi-year study conducted by the Barna Group explores the percentage of Americans who report shifting to a different faith or significantly changing their faith views during their life.

Changing Faith
Anne Rice is not alone. She shares a spiritual profile with nearly 60 million other adults nationwide. In the Barna study, the matter of faith switching was explored in several ways. First, respondents identified their childhood faith, if any, and then were asked to list their current faith allegiance. A comparison of the two answers showed that nearly one-quarter of adults (23%) had moved from one faith or faith tradition to another. This definition of faith change included those who switched from Catholic to Protestant and vice versa, but did not include those who changed from one Protestant denomination to another within the Protestant tradition. Overall, an additional 12% of adults had shifted affiliations but had not altered their Protestant orientation.

Father Steve’s Corner

Steve headshot

Who knew meetings could be this much fun? I sure didn’t. I reported last week on the great meeting we had October 4 about children’s formation.That was followed on Thursday the 8th by a phenomenal meeting of a team that will guide development of our new Saturday evening liturgy. The meeting was filled with laughter, energy, and good ideas. (By the way, that team is being led by MaryAnneO’Rourke. Contact her at mor1313@yahoo.com if you are interested in helping with that liturgy.)

Then this past Sunday we had an equally phenomenal parish meeting. We broke into four groups to consider the four different aspects of what I call the “Invite-Welcome-Nurture-Share” paradigm for growing our church. In that paradigm, we think carefully about effective ways to invite people to St. Nicholas, how to welcome them and help them become a part of the congregation once they come, how to nurture our spiritual growth and meet their – and our — spiritual and human needs, and, finally, how to share with others the gifts of faith and inner growth that we experience.

Each of the breakout groups did a fine job and we were able at the end to react as one large group to their work. We also decided that we will meet again soon to continue our work, focusing on the Invite aspect of the paradigm.

Subsequent meetings will focus on the three other topics. A summary of the ideas generated during this past Sunday’s meeting will be compiled and printed in next week’s One Bread, One Body. For now, two quick comments.

First, thank you to everyone who participated. The turnout was strong and the discussions thorough. There is a lot of energy and commitment at St. Nicholas, and that bodes well as we move forward.

Second, as I said on Sunday, we are clearly in a major structural transition. We have outgrown our old ways of governance and need to grow into new forms. This will not happen overnight, but Sunday’s meeting reassures me that we are on our way.

In particular, we are moving from a system in which I and a few other leaders have been the “visioners” (my awkward term) and “deciders” (W’s awkward term) to one in which many voices contribute and decision-making is more broadly shared.

This is going to be an exciting and engaging transition for both the congregation and for me. On the one hand, my longstanding preference for collaborative leadership will urge me to give away “power” quickly, even gleefully. It is exciting to have people stepping forward, with all sorts of good (if occasionally competing) ideas.

On the other, I know we will need to move forward in ways that a) create a safe container for divergent (and occasionally competing) voices and viewpoints, and b) maintain continuity with — while not genuflecting before — the vision that has attracted so many of us to St. Nicholas.

No doubt this will be challenging, but what a delightful challenge to have before us.

Lots of love,
Steve

Please continue to share your thoughts anything that’s on your mind. Email me at 1bread1body@sbcglobal.net. Or contact me by phone at 630.476.6425.